None of the Above ([info]artis) rakstīja,
@ 2020-06-08 12:52:00

Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Condemn this Violence without Equivocation
"They speak of “deep-rooted systems of oppression; legacies of hate.” No elaboration required here? (..) No nuance or complexity? Is it obvious that “hate”—as opposed to incompetence, or fear, or cruelty, or poor training, or lack of accountability, or a brutal police culture, or panic, or malfeasance—is what we observed in Minneapolis? We are called upon to “effect change.” Change from what to what, exactly? Evidently, we’re now all charged to promote the policy agenda of the “progressive” wing of American politics. Is this what a university is supposed to be doing?

I must object. This is no reasoned ethical reflection. Rather, it is indoctrination, virtue-signaling, and the transparent currying of favor with our charges. The roster of Brown’s “leaders” who signed this manifesto in lockstep remind me of a Soviet Politburo making some party-line declaration. I can only assume that the point here is to forestall any student protests by declaring the university to be on the Right Side of History.

What I found most alarming, though, is that no voice was given to what one might have thought would be a university’s principal intellectual contribution to the national debate at this critical moment: namely, to affirm the primacy of reason over violence in calibrating our reactions to the supposed “oppression.” Equally troubling were our president’s promises to focus the university’s instructional and research resources on “fighting for social justice” around the world, without any mention of the problematic and ambiguous character of those movements which, over the past two centuries or more, have self-consciously defined themselves in just such terms—from the French and Russian Revolutions through the upheavals of the 1960s."

https://www.city-journal.org/brown-university-letter-racism


(Ierakstīt jaunu komentāru)


[info]helvetica
2020-06-08 14:47 (saite)
Cik forši, ka beidzot parādās arī vārdi "nuances & coplexity". Tās ir abās (visās) pusēs un tās būtu jāņem vērā.

(Atbildēt uz šo)


[info]gnidrologs
2020-06-08 21:50 (saite)
Vienkāršāk būtu bijis pateikt elementāru faktu - there's no evidence for "systemic racism", bet saprotu, ka cilvēkiem šādās pozīcijās jālavierē, lai saglabātu ādu (kuru viņi tā pat nesaglabās, jo ar komunistiem nav kompromisu).
Tas, ka murikāņu menti bieži psihi, par to jau nav debate. Tā, lūk, tiešām ir sistēmiska problēma.

(Atbildēt uz šo) (Diskusija)


[info]artis
2020-06-08 21:53 (saite)
Nezinu gan, cik viņam jālavierē, jo tas ir tas prof., kas runā šajā video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDW4CMnugCM&t=20

Nav redzams, ka viņš īpaši mēģinātu runāt caur puķēm.

Drīzāk, ir runa par auditoriju. Te viņš raksta arī kolēģiem.

(Atbildēt uz šo) (Iepriekšējais) (Diskusija)


[info]gnidrologs
2020-06-08 23:14 (saite)
Ā, nu tad jā, pie tam viņam ir zināms kārtblanš kā melnajam (lai gan par onkuli tomu nosauks).

(Atbildēt uz šo) (Iepriekšējais)


Neesi iežurnalējies. Iežurnalēties?