cits ([info]garamgajejs) rakstīja,
@ 2011-10-05 13:58:00

Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Entry tags:anthropology, quote

"In the United States there are few nuances in the popular understanding of the relationships between social structural constraints and individual failure. As a result, intellectuals have retreated from fray and have unreflexively latched on to positive representations of the oppressed that those who have been poor, or lived among the poor, know to be completely unrealistic. Indeed, I have noticed this when presenting the main arguments of this book in academic settings. Progressive and often cultural nationalist colleagues - who are almost always middle class - often seem to be incapable of hearing the arguments I am making. Instead, some react in outrage at superficial images taken out of context. It is as if they are so terrified of the potential for "negative connotations" that they feel compelled to suppress complex, unpleasant messages before even listening to them. Ironically, many of their criticisms in these public academic settings embody central dimensions of precisely what I am trying to convey in these pages about the individual experience of structural oppression."

- Bourgois P., "In Search of Respect: Selling Crack in El Barrio", p.15

Aktuāls piemērs no UK: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-15166189



(Ierakstīt jaunu komentāru)


[info]cannibalsmith
2011-10-06 10:53 (saite)
Lūdzu, atšifrē šo teikumu:
As a result, intellectuals have retreated from fray and have unreflexively latched on to positive representations of the oppressed that those who have been poor, or lived among the poor, know to be completely unrealistic.

(Atbildēt uz šo) (Diskusija)


[info]garamgajejs
2011-10-06 23:58 (saite)
Viņš runā par selektīvu uzmanību pret atsevišķiem pozitīviem sociālās mobilitātes gadījumiem, kas tiek paplašināti kā mēraukla un normatīvs nosacījums dotajai populācijai, neņemot vērā strukturālus ierobežojumus.
"The imperative to sanitize the vulnerable is particularly strong in the United States, where survival-of-the-fittest, blame-the-victim theories of individual action constitute a popular 'common sense'[...] This has seriously limited the ability of intellectuals to debate issues of poverty, ethnic discrimination, and immigration. They are traumatized by the general public's obsession with personal worth and racial determinism".

(Atbildēt uz šo) (Iepriekšējais)


Neesi iežurnalējies. Iežurnalēties?