Philip Greenspun's Weblog's Journal
 
[Most Recent Entries] [Calendar View] [Friends View]

Saturday, January 4th, 2014

    Time Event
    1:35a
    Feel better about your humanities degree: Glenn Beck’s bestselling history book

    Back in 2010 I wrote about Glenn Beck’s salary in comparison with his educational spending (never enrolled in college).

    This evening it was pointed out to me that Glenn Beck, high school graduate, is the author of a New York Times bestseller on American history: Miracles and Massacres: True and Untold Stories of the Making of America. The book gets 4.5 stars from Amazon reviewers, narrowly beating out Pauline Maier’s American Scripture: Making the Declaration of Independence (Vintage) (Maier is a professor at MIT with a PhD in history) and crushing Drew Gilpin Faust’s The Creation of Confederate Nationalism (Faust, possessed of an Ivy League PhD, is now president of Harvard University!).

    11:30p
    Will de Blasio’s new income tax for New Yorkers actually increase income inequality?

    A friend here in Massachusetts was singing the praises of New York’s Mayor de Blasio for adding taxes on high-earners in order to reduce income inequality. It sounds reasonable on its face, but then I remembered my helicopter student, age 39 and about to retire from NYPD on a 100% pension. He was up in Boston attending Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government, courtesy of New York City taxpayers and, once done he was planning to retire to his native Philippines and have New Yorkers wire him money every month.

    Since government workers are paid, on average, more than private sector workers, mightn’t extra taxes that actually increase income inequality? State and local governments overwhelmingly spend money on salaries, health care, and pension benefits for government employees. (See http://seethroughny.net/payrolls/city-of-ny and http://seethroughny.net/index.php?cID=189 for some public-employee salary and pension data.)

    Suppose that the tax rates are left unchanged. The high-income New York City resident now has the money to go out for some additional restaurant meals. for example.  Many restaurant workers earn less than average and probably nearly all earn less than city employees.

    What do readers think? Will inequality of income go up or down in New York City with this new tax?

    [Personally I think that the new tax might not result in much additional cash being collected. A certain number of New Yorkers who currently spend 140 days per year in (potentially tax-free) places other than New York  City might decide to start spending 183 days in those places (see this article on what people are doing already). A handful of businesses will move to places with lower tax rates. So more money will be collected from those who stay for at least 183 days but there will be fewer people from whom to collect tax. This could be a positive for helicopter charter operators as more people try to get out to the Hamptons before midnight (which would tend to reduce income inequality, since helicopter pilots make a lot less than school teachers or police officers!).]

    [There is no question that New York's government needs the money. The Tax Foundation says that New York needs to collect 12.77 percent of state residents' income in order to function (probably higher in the city). This compares to 7.9 percent in Texas, 8.1 percent in New Hampshire, and 10.4 percent in Massachusetts.]

    << Previous Day 2014/01/04
    [Calendar]
    Next Day >>

Philip Greenspun's Weblog   About Sviesta Ciba