|
[3. Jul 2013|19:27] |
http://www.linkedin.com/today/post/article/20130625221857-8451-liberal-arts-and-humanities-education-who-is-right-bill-gates-or-the-late-steve-jobs
Arī komentāri.
My wife was taught music the old-fashioned way .... which means that she was taught to play acording to the set of rules imposed by the sheet music. But no matter how well she can play a piece of music, she cannot improvise. That's right ... she is unable - after all that study, to play what she feels. In other words she cannot think outside of the rules. On the other side of the table is me with my guitar or banjo, and I have been entirely self-taught over the last 30 years, but I taught myself in exactly the opposite way. Sure I had to learn the theory of the fretboard, but as I gathered that knowledge I was set free to experiment. My purpose for learning was because I wanted to express myself and say what I was feeling through my instrument, as opposed to playing what other people had written. As a result, improvisation is my strongest ability. |
|
|
Comments: |
bulšits. Vai nu viņa sieva ir idiote, vai viņu mācīja idiots.
Woman being a woman. Nekāda sakara ar izglītību.
''In other words she cannot think outside of the rules.''
Šis. Tieši šī iemesla dēļ meitenes parasti ir teicamnieces, bet caurmērā švakas ar jebkāda veida darbību, kur nepieciešams radošums, nestandarta domāšana, kas nav iepotējusies caur zubrīšanu. Tas, ka mēdz būt izņēmumi, nenoliedzu.
Nu lai kaut ko tādu apgalvotu, tev vajadzētu kaudzi piemēru, ka sievietes sliktāk improvizē muzikālu instrumentu kā vīrieši.
Kaudze piemēru ir uzkrītošs sieviešu improvizatoru iztrūkums jebkurā mūzikas žanrā, kur improvizācija vispār ir aktuāla.
Nu par to es neko nezinu. Pat ja tā ir, tas hardly ļauj izdarīt vispārīgu secinājumu "woman is just being a woman" un neko intelektuālu radīt nespēj.
Es it kā sapratu, ka empīrisms ir da thing.
Empīrisms nenozīmē automātisku kļūšanu par ekspertu jebkurā tēmā no virspusīgiem vai šauras apakštēmas novērojumiem.
Mani novērojumi šajā sfērā (mūzika) ir visai daudzpusīgi, padziļināti un plašā kontekstā. Un pat ar visu to neuzmetos par ekspertu, tikai konstatēju faktu.
| |